Which NJ Online Sportsbook Is Right For You?

New Jersey was the leading force in bringing legal regulated sports betting to states not named Nevada, so it only makes sense it was the first state to launch online sportsbooks. Since August of last year, nine NJ online sportsbooks have launched, and several more should be live this year, which may leave you wondering which is best for you. Choosing the right online sportsbook depends on what is important to you. Whether you are looking for the best bonuses, ease of use or just want to transition from DFS to sports betting, with a large market in New Jersey, there is an option to suit your needs. Find out which New Jersey online sportsbook is the right one for you!

NJ Online SportsbookPromo Code
888 SportNo Promo Code – Get Bonus Here!
BetStarsNo Promo Code – Get Free Bets Here!
CaesarsComing Soon
DraftKingsNo Promo Code – Get Deposit Bonus!
FanDuelNo Promo Code – Get Risk Free Bet!
playMGMComing Soon
SugarHouseUse Code "GRINDERS"
William HillGRINDERS50
PointsBetUse Promo Code "GRINDERS" – Two Risk-Free Bets Up To $1000
Hard Rock SportsbookComing Soon
Golden Nugget SportsbookComing Soon

DraftKings: For the DFS Convert

Why Choose DraftKings?

Why Not Choose DraftKings?

  • Slow Live In-Game Betting
  • Among the Fewest Withdrawal Methods in NJ
  • No Bonuses Offered After Sign Up Bonuses
  • Very Limited Casino Options

If you are looking to make the exciting transition from DFS to sports betting, DraftKings makes it easy. With shared balances between your fantasy account and sportsbook, you can take advantage of all DraftKings’ bonuses without making a deposit if you have money in your fantasy account. DraftKings $35 no deposit bonus and one time bet match of up to $500 are the biggest in New Jersey.

The simple layout of DraftKings, and user friendly language make it an appealing site for sports betting rookies. There is also a very detailed “quick start guide,” which makes it easy for anyone looking to place their first bet. Player pool betting is set up like an office pool where you pick a contest, pick possible outcomes from various sporting events, and your money is pooled with other players in New Jersey. The more people that join the contest, the bigger the pool grows. The rules for how the pool is spread out among winner varies per contest.

DraftKings has recently added PayPal to their withdrawal and deposit methods but there are still some popular options that DraftKings is missing (an ACH/echeck option, for starters).

Read our full DraftKings online sportsbook review!

$200 Deposit Match Bonus
  • Deposit Match Bonus Up To $200
  • No Code Necessary
  • Features "Cash Out" Betting
  • Bet Sports and Play DFS
$1000 In Risk-Free Bets
  • Use Promo Code GRINDERS
  • Good Odds and Prices
  • Innovative PointsBetting
  • Fantastic Promotions
$500 Free Bet
  • $500 RISK FREE BET
  • No Code Necessary
  • Great Moneyline Odds
  • Easy To Use Interface
$10 No-Deposit Bonus
  • No Promo Code Necessary
  • $10 No Deposit Bonus
  • Sports Betting, Poker and Casino
$500 Free Bet
  • No Code Necessary
  • Great Promotions
  • Bet Sports and Play Poker

FanDuel Sportsbook: For the DFS Convert Who Wants More

Why Choose FanDuel?

  • Shared Balance With Fantasy Sports
  • Risk Free Bet Up to $500
  • Great Promotions
  • Best Lines in New Jersey
  • Wide Selection of Prop and In-Game Betting

Why Not Choose FanDuel?

  • Limited Banking Options
  • Slow Live In-Game Betting
  • No Casino Games

The advantages and disadvantages of choosing FanDuel are very similar to that of DraftKings. Bettors who are transitioning from DFS will find it easy to use their fantasy balance to place wagers in DraftKings’ sportsbook. After the initial $500 free bet, the promotions are fairly limited. Just because they are limited, doesn’t mean they aren’t exciting, though. FanDuel is currently running a promotion for 4+ leg parlays on NBA games where if all win except one, you get a full refund in site credit up to $25.

​Where FanDuel outshines its main rival DraftKings is the variety of prop bets, In-Game bets and lines. These three points can make a huge difference for the serious bettor.

FanDuel’s banking options are similar to DraftKings, with the main difference being you can deposit with ACH/echeck. FanDuel has more than enough options to get money on and off the site, but we would still like to see some more added.

FanDuel offers various oddsboost promos where they will increase the odds in your favor for select games and parlays. FanDuel also offers live In-Game betting but placing a live bet can sometimes become frustrating when the updated odds are delayed and bets sometimes don’t go through.

Read our full FanDuel online sportsbook review!

BetStars: For Poker Players, In-Game Bettors and Frequent Bettors

Why Choose BetStars?

Why Not Choose BetStars?

  • Pregame and In-Game Odds Are Not always the Best

Hidden in the PokerStars mobile app is one of the most aesthetically pleasing and innovative sports betting apps in New Jersey. When you sign up and place your first $50 in sports bets, you will receive a free $50 bet. After the initial $50 free bet, every $150 you wager will garner you an additional $50 free bets up to $500 in bonus bets. Every week that you wager at least $25, you will receive a $5 free bet. In addition to all the free bets, BetStars offers the most oddsboost promos in New Jersey. Every night, BetStars offers increased odds on basically every major game from player props to boosted odds on parlays. BetStars is also running a parlay bonus promo where the more games you add, the bigger the bonus added up to 100% on 18 game parlays.

BetStars is a great option for experienced sports bettors and beginners alike. BetStars’ fun and exciting platform is very easy to navigate with quick loading and constantly updating odds. While point spread bets seem to be on par with the rest of the industry, some single moneyline bets may leave bettors slightly disappointed. While not the worst in the New Jersey market, you may benefit from shopping around if you feel the lines are a bit low.

Read our full BetStars online sportsbook review!

SugarHouse: For Bonus Seekers and In-Game Bettors

Why choose SugarHouse?

Why Not Choose SugarHouse?

  • Loyalty Program is Hard to Maintain
  • Can Not See Lines From Out of State

SugarHouse is a great option for anyone looking to get started in the New Jersey sports betting market. The first deposit bonus comes with an unheard of 1x wagering bonus. Unlike DraftKings or FanDuel, where the first deposit bonus has to be used in one large bet, SugarHouse immediately credits your account 100% up to $250, which can then be used on a eries of smaller bets such as 10 $25 bets or 25 $10 bets. This is a great option for bettors who want to try out SugarHouse’s large selection of In-Game betting where bets can be placed for as low as 10 cents. Casino wagers also count towards the wagering requirements, and with the shared wallet you can take a few spins on your favorite slot while you wait for your bets to be settled.

SugarHouse’s loyalty program can be a bit tough to maintain. Points expire fairly quick, so if you are not placing a large amount of wagers consistently, you may find yourself struggling to move up the ladder. If you are a high volume bettor and are able to make your way up to a high level, you will be rewarded with very generous deposit bonuses, which all carry that extremely low 1x wagering requirement.

Although you have to physically be located in New Jersey to place a bet, most sites allow you to see the lines from out of state. For those bettors that drive across the border to place bets and return home, you will have to wait until you are actually in New Jersey to put together your bets and you will not have access to your placed bets outside of New Jersey so be sure to take screen shots or write down your placed bets before returning home.

Check our our full SugarHouse online sportsbook review!

888sport: For Large Volume Bettors and Bonus Seekers

Why Choose 888sport?

Why Not Choose 888sport?

  • Hefty Wagering Requirements on Bonuses (6x)
  • Support Can Be Hard to Reach

888sport is offering the biggest first deposit bonus in the Garden State, but they are going to make you work for it. You are required to wager at least 6x your first deposit in the first 30 days to make the bonus available for withdrawal. This means if you take full advantage of the $500 deposit bonus, you will need to wager $3000 in the first 30 days on bets with -200 or higher odds.

With every sport from Football to darts, 888sport has you covered no matter what your favorite sport is. In addition to the large selection of betting markets, 888sport offers a huge selection of pregame and In-Game betting options. For example, a typical NFL game may offer 90-100 pregame bets, and even more options In-Game.

888sport shares their wallet with 888casino and 888poker, so while you are watching your favorite team waiting for your bets to be settled, you can play a few hands of blackjack or sit down at the virtual poker table.

Read our full 888sports online sportsbook review!

William Hill: For Those Looking for a Live Sportsbook, But Online

Why Choose William Hill?

  • Bet $50, Get $50 Cash Promotion (Use promo code GRINDERS50)
  • Simple, Easy to Use Interface

Why Not Choose William Hill?

  • Very Limited In-Game Betting Options
  • Extremely Limited Banking Options
  • No Loyalty Program

William Hill is offering a bet $50, get $50 for new users. Just deposit $50, make at least $50 in wagers, and they will put $50 in your account within 48 hours. Despite having an affiliation with one of the most exciting live sportsbooks in Atlantic City at Oceans Casino, there isn’t too much to be excited about when it comes to their online sportsbook offering. William Hill online sportsbook has a very basic layout, limited In-Game options on a very limited amount of select games, and extremely limited banking options. The only two withdrawal options are to pick up your money at the Oceans casino cage, or sign up for the William Hill play+ card. William Hill’s online offerings feel just like an extension of its live sportsbook, and we would look forward to seeing how William Hill will improve its online book in the future.

Check out our full William Hill Sportsbook review!

Caesars: For Those Looking for Total Rewards Points

Why Choose Caesars?

  • Tied-In With Live Casino Total Rewards Program
  • $10 No-Deposit Sign-Up Bonus, and Up to $300 Deposit Match Free Bet for New Customers
  • Shared balance with casino

Why Not Choose Caesars?

  • Limited In-Game Betting Options

If one word pops in my head when I think of Caesars online sportsbook, it would be adequate. Caesars online sportsbook runs like a live sportsbook, with a few extras. While they offer In-Game betting, its very limited to certain games, and very limited on betting markets. The loyalty program is tied-in to the live Total Rewards, and you have your choice of rolling online rewards points into your Total Rewards account, or converting to cash. Prop bets are offered on select games, but as with everything else, there are only select markets available.

Read our full Caesars online sportsbook review!

PlayMGM: A Prop Bettor’s Paradise

Why Choose PlayMGM?

  • Huge Selection of Prop Bets
  • One Time $25 Risk Free Bet
  • Backed by The Borgata
  • Shared Balance With Poker and Casino
  • Large Variety of Betting Markets

Why Not Choose PlayMGM?

  • No Loyalty Program
  • Extremely Basic Setup
  • Very Limited In-Game Betting

PlayMGM is offering a meager $25 risk free first bet for new customers, but if you already have a poker or casino account, you are not eligible for this promotion. PlayMGM has a very simple, almost boring layout, and an adequate amount of banking options. Despite not being the most exciting online sportsbook, where PlayMGM really shines is their wide selection of prop bets. Almost every game has hundreds of options for player props, alternative lines, team props and scoring props. For example, they are the only site in New Jersey to offer over/under lines on every player in every game played. PlayMGM also has one of the largest variety of sports available to place wagers on as well.

PlayMGM does offer In-Game betting, but is very limited to select games and markets. If you are looking for In-Game options, you may be happier shopping around elsewhere after placing your pregame prop bets at MGM.

Read our full PlayMGM sports betting review!

PointsBet: The User Friendly Sportsbook

Why Choose PointsBet?

  • Great Promos
  • Great lines
  • Innovative Pointsbetting

Why not choose PointsBet?

  • No teaser bets
  • Can be a bit volatile

PointsBet is offering Two Risk-Free Bets Up To $1000. One is on a standard sportsbet and the other is their innovative PointsBetting product. PointsBetting takes a traditional wager like a spread, total or prop bet and adds an exciting twist where the potential winnings (or losses) aren’t fixed, but vary by the outcome at the end of a game.

Pointsbet are constantly updating their promotions that include no juice spreads, good karma payouts where if a game is decided by a controversial call, bets can be refunded and parlay insurance where if one leg of 4+ leg a parlay loses, you get a refund in bonus bets.

Read our full PointsBet review here!

Golden Nugget: Online Casino patrons who want to try sports betting

Why Choose Golden Nugget?

  • Free $50 risk free bet
  • Easy to use
  • Shared balance with online casino

Why not choose Golden Nugget?

  • NO NBA betting
  • Generic online sportsbook

Golden Nugget is offering a $50 risk free bet in exchange for you trying out their relatively new sportsbook. There is nothing inherently special about Golden Nuggets online sportsbook, and due to their owner being part owner of the Houston Rockets, there are no NBA bets offered. Their easy to use software and shared balance with the top New Jersey online casino should make this a popular option for casino customers that want to take their first shot at sports betting.

Read our full Golden Nugget review here!

Hard Rock: For Live and Online Hard Rock Casino Patrons

Why choose Hard Rock?

  • One time $100 true risk free bet
  • Shared balance with online casino
  • Generous online casino bonuses

Why not choose Hard Rock?

  • Generic online sportsbook

Hard Rock online sportsbook is offering a truly risk free sports bet of $100. Unlike other “risk free bets” where they refund your first losing bet in the form of a bonus bet, Hard Rock will refund your account with $100 cash that can be instantly withdrawn if your bet loses. Hard Rock also has a shared balance with their online casino that offers several exciting promotions that include a $1000 first deposit match and perks that include free stays at the exciting new casino.

Hard Rock covers all the popular sports betting markets with all the popular bets including moneyline, parlays, spreads and prop bets on most games.

Read our full Hard Rock review here!

Whether you are new to sports betting or a seasoned veteran, New Jersey sportsbooks have you covered. There are plenty of promotions out there to help you shop around and find the right sites that suit you best. Check back with RotoGrinders for updates on all your New Jersey sports betting promos, site launches and sportsbook updates.

About the Author

  • Ryan Gutzler (rgutzler)

  • Ryan is a former two sport collegiate athlete who now relives the glory days through men’s leagues, coaching and of course, writing about sports. He is also a poker player, sports bettor and avid Sixers, Phillies, Flyers and Duke homer.