Underdog Pick'em Contests: How to Play and Strategies for Winning
Underdog pick’em contests are as straightforward as DFS gets—just pick more or less for projected player stats, and wait for your entry’s outcome.
It might be simple to play pick’em at Underdog, but it’s a lot harder to win. Fortunately, I’m here to share the best tips for building your entries and crafting winning strategies. I’ll also go over more generally how Underdog pick’em works, as I know not everyone is familiar with how this operator approaches the game.
What Are Underdog Pick ’em Contests?
Like other top DFS apps, Underdog hosts pick’em contests that mimic the over/under style of traditional prop betting. It’s one of the several game formats available on the app alongside Drafts and Champions (that is, if you’re lucky enough to play from an eligible state).
It really is as simple as it gets—add at least two players to your entry and select whether they will earn MORE or LESS than their projected stats (three-pointers, touchdowns, rushing yards, etc.). In most cases, all of your picks have to be right to get a payout. And the bigger your entry, the higher your payout will be.
The game is super dynamic—if your player doesn’t play, the pick will become void while the rest of your entry is still eligible for a win. If one of your players exits the game early due to injury or gets little playing time, sorry, but you’ll lose the entry if they didn’t get enough time to hit your projections.
In the example above, Underdog had Joe Burrow throwing for 1.5 touchdowns in the Cincinnati vs. Tennessee game, and I had a feeling that his bad luck from the 2024 season was going to turn around. I was right, and so was my intuition that Rodgers would throw 0 INTs in the Jets vs. Jaguars game.
Unfortunately, Derrick Henry’s longest rush of the Ravens vs. Giants game was less than 19.5 yards, and without any protections, this entry busted.
Underdog Rivals
Underdog Rivals takes its pick’em contests a step further.
In Rivals, you create head-to-head player matchups. For instance, you might pit Christian McCaffrey against against Saquon Barkley to rush for more yards.
Rivals matchups on Underdog usually have adjustments to even the playing field (like in the matchup mentioned, McCaffrey might be +5.5, meaning a correct pick for him would require him to not only rush more yards than Barkley but rush 5.5 more).
Sound familiar? Rivals essentially combines player props and spreads from traditional sports betting but are categorized as daily fantasy sports, meaning you can participate in these contests where Underdog pick’em is legal.
To learn more about the up to 1000x payouts on pick’em contests, check out our guide to Underdog Streaks.
How to Get Started with Underdog Pick’em
It was easy for me to join this DFS app with the Underdog promo code—the signup process was quick, and I got a boost with the help of the generous welcome offer.
Here’s an overview of how to get started with Underdog pick’em contests:
Creating Your Account
You can click our links to create an account, but make sure that promo code
You’ll also have to provide a username, password, email address, and your DOB. The minimum deposit is $10, and once you fund your account via a method like PayPal or debit/credit card, you’ll get the welcome offer of:
Making Your First Selections
After setting up your account, it’s time to make your first picks. Underdog releases projections for various sports, giving you tons of options to choose from (though I’m particularly fond of NBA).
Some things to keep in mind as you build your entries:
- Each entry has to have at least two players, and the max is 8.
- Entries must contain players from at least two different teams. So, you couldn’t have an entry with only Baker Mayfield and Mike Evans since they’re both on the Bucs.
- Once you submit your selections, they cannot be edited or canceled, so make your final decision wisely.
Navigating the Platform
Navigating the Underdog platform is easy. The main categories include drafts and pick ’em, making finding what you’re looking for easy.
I’d recommend using the Underdog tracker to find the most recently placed picks and analyze their performance, as it’s a good way to see what has worked in the past (and what hasn’t).
In the Lone Star State? See our review of Underdog Texas.
Strategies for Winning Underdog Pick ’em Contests
Winning in Underdog Pick ’em contests requires a mix of research, strategy, and a bit of luck.
Here are some tips that I’ve used to find success on the platform:
Researching Player Performance
One of the keys to success in Pick’em contests is thorough research. Delve into player performance metrics like Expected Points Added (EPA) and efficiency ratings.
If all of that sounds confusing, turn to expert analysis. You might read up on valuable insights into player health and injury status, helping you make more informed selections.
To make things even simpler, use our Underdog Fantasy Picks today tool. It updates every 10 minutes with data-backed predictions so you can easily determine whether to go MORE or LESS.
Understanding Matchup Dynamics
This tip applies specifically to the Rivals portion of Underdog pick’em contests. You’ll want to know the resources each player has on their side to help predict how they’ll do against their rival.
You can analyze everything from red zone efficiency to defensive rankings, but it often boils down to common sense.
For instance, if you have McCaffrey and Barkley going up against each other, consider the performance of their offensive lines. If the 49ers aren’t doing too hot, you might see Barkley as favorable especially if McCaffrey has to overcome an adjustment.
Combining Picks for Maximum Payouts
Combining picks effectively can lead to higher payouts.
For instance, combining a quarterback’s passing yards with a receiver’s receiving yards on the same entry can be a winning strategy (though, remember, you would need to throw a player from another team on the entry as well for it to be valid).
Another example: Let’s say you pick a QB to throw more than their projected interceptions and an opposing WR to get more than their projected interceptions. These picks jive well as they help build on each other.
Using Protection
Underdog promos are available to offer pick protection, meaning you can still win your entry even if a pick loses. Most notably, there are Flex entries that let you opt for lower multipliers in exchange for pick protection.
While insured payouts offer a safety net, they come with smaller returns, so choose your strategy wisely.
Playing for Fun
At the end of the day, Underdog pick’em is meant for entertainment so play within your means and pick what excites you. It has to be a really good deal for me to pick LESS, as I’m a bit of a softie and don’t want to root for a player to have a poor performance or even an injury.
Managing Your Bankroll in Underdog Pick ’em
Effective bankroll management is crucial for long-term success in Underdog Pick ’em contests. Here are some ways to keep your spending on the app in check:
Set a Budget
Setting a budget is the first step in managing your bankroll. Allocate a specific amount for weekly plays to control spending, and only play with what you can afford to lose.
For instance, you might set aside $10 a week to play pick’em contests. Maybe you might use your winnings to play more, but you should stick to your commitment of not spending more. If you lose your $10 for the week, don’t try to win it back—just wait until the next week.
Spread Out Your Budget
While some people are disciplined enough to spend all of their allocated amount on one contest, consider if diversifying is the right approach for you. You might find more satisfaction in playing 5 different contests for $2 instead of $10 on one contest, as if you lose, you might be more inclined to go beyond your budget to chase a win.
Adjust Based on Performance
Adjusting your strategy based on past performance is key to optimizing your chances of success. Regularly reassess your wins and losses to make informed decisions in future contests. Modifying your bet sizes or entry amounts based on recent performance can help prevent emotional decision-making and enhance your overall strategy.
Legal Considerations for Underdog Pick ’em Contests
The legal status of Underdog pick’em contests varies by state, so always verify your local regulations to ensure compliance.
Where You Can Play
Underdog pick ’em contests are permitted in 19 states across the U.S.:
- Alaska
- California
- Georgia
- Indiana
- Kentucky
- Minnesota
- Nebraska
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Dakota
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Wisconsin
Underdog Fantasy itself is available in 40 states plus D.C., but legal regulations restrict the types of contests allowed in each state. For instance, Underdog Fantasy Florida has Champions and Drafts but not pick’em. Champions is actually pretty similar to pick’em contests, but users play against other users rather than against the house.
Always check local laws and restrictions before participating to ensure you’re playing legally.
Age and Eligibility Requirements
Age requirements for participation in Underdog pick ’em contests vary by state.
Generally, players must be at least 18 years old. Some states like Nebraska are 19+ while others are 21+ depending on the contest.
Ensure you meet your state’s minimum age and eligibility requirements before playing.
Responsible Gaming Practices
Underdog Fantasy promotes responsible gaming by providing resources and guidance for players who need help. Engaging in responsible gaming practices is crucial for sustaining enjoyment and minimizing risk.
Use the available resources to manage your gaming habits effectively and ensure a safe and enjoyable experience.
Comparing Underdog Pick ’em to Other Platforms
Underdog Pick ’em stands out in the daily fantasy sports sector, but how does it compare to other platforms? This section highlights Underdog Fantasy’s unique features, payout structures, and user experience compared to its competitors.
Unique Features of Underdog
Underdog Fantasy offers unique features like Rivals, a head-to-head contest format where players can make picks comparing two players. The Flex insured entry option also sets Underdog apart, providing payouts even if not all picks are correct.
Additionally, Best Ball contests add more engagement beyond standard Pick ’em formats.
Payout Structures Comparison
When it comes to payouts, Underdog offers both standard and insured play options, including various payout options. Underdog provides higher payouts for specific entry types than competitors, such as a 6x payout for three correct picks versus a 5x payout on PrizePicks. See our PrizePicks promo code review and apps like PrizePicks guide for more info.
This flexibility in payout structures makes Underdog an attractive choice for players seeking better returns.
User Experience and Interface
Underdog Fantasy is noted for its intuitive user interface, which streamlines the contest selection process. The platform’s design ensures a smooth and enjoyable user experience, making it easy for players to navigate and make their picks.
Advanced Tips for Seasoned Players
Advanced strategies can significantly improve performance for seasoned players looking to elevate their game.
Leveraging Advanced Stats
Using advanced statistics can significantly enhance your decision-making process in Underdog pick ’em contests. For instance, incorporating advanced metrics like expected value (EV) betting helps you make informed choices based on statistical advantages.
Following Expert Insights
Following expert insights can provide a significant edge in Underdog Pick ’em contests. I’ve seen several experts recommend using 3-way and 5-way entries to maximize potential payouts, though you can see what others have to say, too.
Adapting to Season Trends
Adapting your approach throughout the NFL season is crucial for success in Underdog Pick ’em contests. Monitor seasonal trends, such as shifts in team strength and emerging players, to refine your strategies continuously. Data analysis tools and expert insights can help you stay ahead of the curve and make more informed picks.
Underdog Pick’em Contests: Final Thoughts
Winning big in Underdog Pick ’em contests requires a strategic approach, thorough research, and effective bankroll management. By following the tips and strategies outlined in this guide, you’ll be well-equipped to make informed picks and maximize your chances of winning.
Remember, the key to success lies in continuous learning and adaptation. Happy picking!
Underdog Pick’em FAQs
Below are some FAQs regarding Underdog Pick ’em contests.
What are Underdog Pick ’em contests?
Underdog Pick ’em contests are all about guessing how players will perform in different sports by picking at least two MORE/LESS player stats from separate teams. It’s a fun way to test your sports knowledge and potentially win cash.
How do I create an account on Underdog?
To get started, head to Underdog’s site, enter your email, create a password, and use promo code
What are some strategies for winning Underdog Pick ’em contests?
To win Underdog Pick ’em contests, dive into player performance stats, grasp the matchups, and mix your picks for better payouts. Staying updated with expert insights and seasonal trends will give you an edge!
Where can I legally play Underdog Pick ’em contests?
You can legally play Underdog Pick ’em contests in 19 states: AK, CA, GA, IN, KY, MN, NE, NM, NY, ND, OK, OR, RI, SC, SD, TX, UT, VT, and WI.
How can I manage my bankroll effectively in Underdog Pick ’em contests?
To manage your bankroll effectively in Underdog Pick ’em contests, set a clear budget and stick to it while tracking your spending. Regularly reassess your strategy based on your performance to keep everything sustainable.