Sports Card Targets - Top QB Legends to Target

We’re going to dive into some classic cards in this week’s article. We’ve seen a recent jump in nostalgic cards like Michael Jordan, Mark McGwire/Sammy Sosa, and Ken Griffey Jr which got me researching older cards. We want to focus on scarcity from those eras due to the massive overprinting the card companies did back then, so most of the cards we look at this week will be graded or autographed. If you’re new to Sports Card Investing and wondering which rookie cards to buy, is a great resource. They put out “rookie checklist” articles listing popular rookie cards for most popular players which makes your research much easier. We’ll focus once again at QBs and this week and look at some modern-day legends.

We will generally target Panini brands for football as they own exclusive NFL rights for sports cards. This week, though, since the cards are older we will have a wider range of brands. Just like DFS, be sure to manage your bankroll and don’t spend more than what your budget allows. Make sure you pay attention to the grading when looking at targets. Grading makes a huge difference in price, so price targets will be based on grading. An ungraded card is referred to as “Raw”. When targeting a Raw card, try to find one with the best centering, corners and edges (and surface if you can tell) as that is a card that might be worth sending in for grading. We’ll use SportsCardInvestor’s Market Movers data to evaluate current-market price targets based on what people have been paying most recently. Go above/below that market rate based on your convictions and confidence levels by player. Be sure to subscribe using this link or use the promo code GRINDERS for your 20% off your first payment with SCI.

Sports Card Investing – 5 QB Legends To Target

Company Disclaimer: We may be compensated by the company links provided on this page

4) Aaron Rodgers & Brett Favre – I’m going to lump these two together. I didn’t like the options for Favre rookies as he was right in the thick of the 90’s cards I want to avoid, and we have a preferred legend higher on this list who also has cards from that era. Rodgers, on the other hand, is also HOF bound, has RPAs available (scarcity!), and still has plenty of catalysts left to drive his card prices higher. He’s not really a legend yet (sorry Beer), but if we lump him with Favre we can consider them part of the legend of Green Bay. As you can see from the chart of Rodgers’ Contenders Rookie Auto card, his trend is down too which is what we like when making an investment like this.

Cards To Target:

Chart Courtesy of

2005 Exquisite Collection Aaron Rodgers RC #106 Autographed Jersey #/199 Raw – Target Under $930

2005 Playoff Contenders Aaron Rodgers RC #101 Autograph BGS 9.5 – Target Under $3,400

Chart Courtesy of

1991 Brett Favre Topps Stadium Club PSA 10 – Target Under $420

3) Drew Brees – Brees in a no-brainer in a category like this. He is a 1st-ballot Hall Of Fame QB who is still playing at a high level. He owns a bunch of major records, he’s got a ring, and plays for a team that is consistently at the top of their division (although he will face new competition this season from another legend). With lots of catalyst potential remaining in his career, it makes sense to have this legend on your target list.

Cards To Target:

2001 Drew Brees Playoff Contenders Rookie Auto /500 Raw – Target Under $2,600

2001 Topps Chrome Refractor Drew Brees ROOKIE RC /999 #229 PSA 9 – Target Under $2,850

2001 Drew Brees SPx Auto Jersey Patch /250 Raw (note – I’d prefer this card graded but with the scarcity of the card it’s difficult to determine a target price. Most recent PSA 9 sold for $900 though if you need a reference) – Target Under $405

2) Peyton Manning – Like Favre, Manning also falls in that ‘90s-range of cards we prefer to avoid. But Manning is too big a legend to ignore and still has some decent cards to target. He’s right up there with Brady as far as being under consideration as the greatest of all time and his name still carries a lot of weight. I would not be surprised to see a Manning documentary come out similar to Michael Jordan’s after the success of “The Last Dance” which drove Jordan’s prices through the roof.

Cards To Target:

Chart Courtesy of

1998 Peyton manning SP Authentic BGS 9.5 – Target Under $2,200

1998 Peyton Manning Topps Chrome BGS 9.5 – Target Under $550

1998 Peyton Manning SPx Finite BGS 9 – Target Under $400

1) Tom Brady – I featured Brady in my Tampa Bay article a few weeks ago and this week he is at the top of the list of legend targets. Like Brees and Rodgers, Brady is still active and on a contending team. In fact, Brady might have the best weapons out of the group which makes him interesting in the face of his declining performance. We’re more focused on a longer-term hold here though as opposed to a flip so there is more future upside than near-term downside downside which makes this GOAT a good target. We’ll include his $33k card just to demonstrate the potential of the Sports Card market.

Cards To Target:

2000 Tom Brady Contenders Football Auto BGS 9 – Target Under $33,655

2000 Tom Brady SP Authentic BGS 9.5 – Target Under $12,000

Chart Courtesy of

2000 Tom Brady SPx #130 BGS 9 – Target Under $2,300

About the Author

  • Simon Edwards (Pumacom)

  • Simon is a long-time sports card collector who spent the majority of his cash as a kid investing in cards to sell at card shows. In 2009-2010 he owned an affiliate collectables website along with sports-card legend, Don West, where they did box breaks and sold cards. Simon recently got back into sports card investing after the market reset itself and investability returned to the market.


  • X Unread Thread
  • X Thread with New Replies*
  • *Jumps to your first unread reply

New to DFS?

Be sure to click through our links and use our exclusive promo codes to receive the industry's best sign-up bonuses, including free access to our premium content. is the home of the daily fantasy sports community. Our content, rankings, member blogs, promotions and forum discussion all cater to the players that like to create a new fantasy team every day of the week. Our goal is to help all of our members make more money playing daily fantasy sports!

Bet with your head, not over it!
Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-Gambler