The Sporer Report: Week 14

Welcome to The Sporer Report. It is designed to set up the week from a pitching perspective. Once the season gets rolling, Mondays become one of the regularly scheduled off days, so the slates will often be lighter and that allows us some time to plan for the remaining six days of the week, five of which will have full slates (Thursday is the other regular off-day).

Felix Hernandez

Each week I will deep-dive the projected starters rundown identifying the best starts of the week, the potential value plays on the docket, and the starts where an otherwise strong asset may find some trouble. Additionally, I will rank my top 10 and bottom 10 bullpens. The importance here is two-fold: 1) you want to be careful betting on weak bullpens as it could cost you starter wins which is especially important if they are highly valued (like DraftDay where they are 10 points) and 2) if you’re stacking against some tomato can, you don’t really want him to be reinforced by a top bullpen because that could stunt your stack when the starter is lifted after two-plus innings and you didn’t get nearly the points you expected.

This is the outline for now as we start the season, but I’m certain I will be adding in-season as ideas pop up. In fact, if you have any pitching-related items you’d like to see included in the Weekly Report, please let me know in the comments or on Twitter. Also remember that anytime we are dealing with projected starters, the key is the projected part of it. They are subject to change, especially the ones later in the week.

Editor’s Note: This report is compiled early Monday morning. Scheduled pitching assignments are subject to change throughout the week.

TOP 35 STARTS (JUST THE BEST, REGARDLESS OF PRICE)

We’re just looking for the best potential payoff here. A lot of these guys will be the expensive arms atop the slate, but that investment will likely pay dividends. These are the guys you will be looking to in 50/50s and H2H matchups because there is just little chance of a total meltdown.

TOP 35 STARTS

RK PITCHER OPP DAY NOTE
1 Max Scherzer CIN Tue He’s averaging about 34 points per start over his L10 over at DK; had >2 BBs in 11 starts last year, hasn’t done it yet this year
2 Chris Sale at CHC Sat Has a silly 43% K rate over his last 8 w/10+ in each (going for record v. TOR); CHC fans more v. RHP, but that won’t stop him here
3 Clayton Kershaw PHI Wed Led MLB w/10.8 K/9 last year; he’s added nearly a full K (11.6), but sits only second because of Sale
4 Zack Greinke PHI Thu The price split between the two LAD aces is bigger than the talent gap almost making Greinke “a value” even w/a top flight price tag
5 Madison Bumgarner PHI Fri Aside from two clunkers, this is essentially a ’14 carbon copy; the clunkers count, but if he cuts ‘em out he’s back to a mid-2.00s level
6 Gerrit Cole StL Fri Not dying to use him against StL, but if they drop his price substantially ($8000-something?) I’d be more than willing to jump on board
7 Felix Hernandez LAA Thu Has a 1.95 ERA in 27.7 IP with 24 Ks in four starts since the Bronx destruction incl. six-shutout v. LAA; has 0.90 ERA in 20 IP v. LAA this year (26 Ks)
8 Jake Arrieta CWS Sun Only has one 10-K outing, but has consistency as one of just 5 arms w/5+ K in 16+ starts (Kershaw, Shields, Hamels, and Archer)
9 David Price at MIN Thu Doing what he can to avoid giving bullpen much work: avg’ing over 7 IP/GS in last 12 w/rain delay the only reason he hasn’t gone 6+ in all of em
10 Corey Kluber HOU Tue Has a 3.86 ERA, 1.17 WHIP w/45 Ks and 4.1 K:BB in his last 42 IP… he’s 0-4 in those six starts; HOU K’ing 28% in last month v. RHP (26% for seas.)
11 Corey Kluber OAK Sun I don’t usually care about W-L rec., but DFS gives them renewed focus and unfortunately his has lagged badly and costs him a couple spots
12 Matt Harvey ARI Sat Are the 5 BBs indication of another down spell or just a tough outing? He’s going to be mostly excellent, but a few duds are part of TJ returns
13 Carlos Carrasco HOU Mon It’s only three starts, but since the Lindor-Urshela defensive boost: 2.31 ERA, 0.82 WHIP, 25 Ks, 8.3 K:BB in 20.3 IP
14 Michael Wacha at CHC Wed His 25% K rate since mid-May is 25th-best in baseball
15 Carlos Carrasco OAK Sat The near no-hitter was a perfect microcosm of why there’s so much hype on Carrasco, even as he’s held a 4.00-something for most of the yr
16 Jake Arrieta StL Tue Over his L10, he’s average 24.7 points over at DK, which is equal to Kershaw’s season avg; not bad company to keep, Arrieta is a stud
17 Johnny Cueto at MIA Sun Has allowed more than 3 ER just once in his eight reeling off a 2.70 ERA, 0.96 WHIP, and 53 Ks in 53.3 IP
18 Cole Hamels at SF Fri SF isn’t a walkover, but they’re average v. LH for the season and well below that over the last month (21st in wOBA)
19 Jacob deGrom at SF Wed SF gets these two in back-to-back gms, but at least there’s an off-day in between; JdG’s follow up is even more impressive than the ROY in ’14
20 Chris Archer at KC Wed Can succeed w/out the Ks which is necessary v. KC, but Ks also drive DFS scores so he has to drop a few spots against them
21 Dallas Keuchel at CLE Mon Because he lacks consistently large K totals, he’s become a boom-bust play probably best-suited for tournaments
22 Dallas Keuchel at TB Sat When on, he’s dropping 40-pt night-makers, but there are a lot of solid-but-unspectacular upper-teens scores when he isn’t going 8-9 IP
23 Carlos Martinez at PIT Thu Get your CarMart while you can bc his 100 IP are already more than last year’s 99 so StL might have to get creative w/him to have him for Oct.
24 Johnny Cueto at WAS Tue Harper is the only monster in that lineup right now, but Cueto’s .505 OPS v. LHP is the best among righties this yr (Scherzer 2nd at .533)
25 Jason Hammel StL Wed Continues to show that ’14 was legit, but his price is one of the best among high-quality arms; has 14 gms of 5+ Ks (tied w/Kluber, Carrasco)
26 Jose Fernandez at BOS Thu Showed everything you could’ve hoped for in his return; it’ll be similar to Harvey’s in that there will be hiccups, but the stuff is there
27 Lance Lynn at PIT Fri Has allowed just 11 H and 1 ER (2 R total) in 19 IP since returning from the DL w/20 Ks
28 A.J. Burnett SD Mon I don’t think you can comfortably call Burnett or Liriano an unqualified ace, but both are pitching like aces often, giving the Pirates three aces
29 Francisco Liriano SD Tue SD is looking way too much like the 2014 version this year sitting bottom 10 against both lefties and righties
30 Michael Pineda at BOS Fri The volatility lowers his cash game appeal, but the base skills are cash game gold (25% K rate, 8.1 K:BB ratio, 50% GB)
31 Francisco Liriano StL Sun Lefties are about the only weakness for StL; Liriano has been both good and bad against them this year in back-to-back starts to open May
32 Jordan Zimmermann at BAL Sat Looking like Vintage JZ of late: 1.21 ERA, 0.84 WHIP, 25 Ks, and 12.5 K:BB ratio in 29.7 IP
33 Noah Syndergaard ARI Fri Dodgers Schmodgers: six innings of two-hit ball; he’s been dominant since those two 10-hit gms (2.25 ERA, 0.88 WHIP, 25 Ks in 24 IP)
34 Hector Santiago at SEA Fri Displaying the best skills of his career; fly-ball tendencies always keep HRs in play, but SEA has been brutal v. LHP of late (30th in wOBA in L30)
35 Brett Anderson PHI Tue Loving the K outburst of late (17 in L2 starts), but even w/out them his price is low enough to be at least a solid SP2

POTENTIAL VALUE STARTS (CHEAPER GUYS WORTH CONSIDERING)

These guys are very unlikely to be among the highest priced arms on the board, but obviously that juicy price point comes with risk. Just how much risk will vary depending on the slate, but there is almost always some value to be mined in the pitching pool. We swim in this pool understanding that they will bust at times and tank a lineup, but the potential upside is enough to incur that risk. These guys make great off-the-radar gambles for larger scale tournaments where you need some uniqueness to hit big.

POTENTIAL VALUE STARTS

RK PITCHER OPP DAY NOTE
1 Brett Anderson PHI Tue He’s topped $7000 just once in his last 10 games (2.76 ERA); WHIP concerns make him a better FD play v. tougher tms
2 Jake Odorizzi HOU Sat Slated to return from his oblique injury after just over a month off, it should drop his price
3 Eduardo Rodriguez NYY Sat Really impressive two-start week last week, incl. the trip to TOR; if tipping is under control, watch out
4 Lance McCullers Jr. at TB Fri Seemed to have either a blister or broken nail toward end of last start, that’s about all that can stop him right now
5 Steven Matz ARI Sun Tempering expectations is hard when he’s up throwing 95 from the left side and blitzing LAD in their park
6 Anibal Sanchez at SEA Wed It’s all about HR suppression and SEA gives him a great chance to go HR-free
7 Chris Heston PHI Sun The no-no came on the road, but his 3.12 home ERA is much better than his 4.44 on the road
8 Jose Quintana at CHC Sun Now 7 straight of 3 or fewer ER yielding a 2.78 ERA in his last 45.3 IP
9 Chris Heston NYM Mon NYM is probably a good bit worse than they were at the time of the no-no
10 Ubaldo Jimenez at MIN Wed He’s morphed into a value play as he’s found some consistency w/that new BB%
11 Mat Latos CIN Sat Since returning from the DL: 3.31 ERA, 0.95 WHIP, 31 Ks, and 3.9 K:BB ratio in 32.7 IP
12 Wei-Yin Chen at MIN Mon Career-best 7.9 H/9 has tempered the impact of career-high 1.4 HR/9; MIN not a huge HR threat
13 Andrew Heaney at SEA Sun Yeah, I’m just picking on SEA a lot this week; Heaney has been v sharp in two outing so far
14 Kendall Graveman at CLE Sat Has gone 7+ IP in each of his last six which mitigates the very modest 16% K rate in the same span

POTENTIAL LANDMINES (QUALITY ARMS WHO COULD STUMBLE)

Sometimes you think you’ve got a great option for the day. Maybe he’s an expensive guy who has the track record worth trusting or perhaps you’re speculating a bit further down the list and feel like the matchup merits a gamble. However, that stud might not be as sturdy as you think and maybe the team your gamble is facing can’t hit on the whole, but the one thing they do well is the exact weakness of your gamble play. Every week will have potential landmines, upper- and mid-tier arms in a presumed rosterable spot who might actually be in for an implosion. These are listed with the scariest at the top (so most potential to largely underperform against expectations).

POTENTIAL LANDMINES

RK PITCHER OPP DAY NOTE
1 Shelby Miller at COL Fri It’s Coors, you know the drill
2 James Shields at TEX Sun It’s less about the park and more just the TEX offense and its ability to decimate RHP (.367 wOBA in L30, 1st in MLB)
3 Clay Buchholz NYY Fri Pitching brilliantly of late, but NYY owns him: 6.38 ERA in 85 IP incl. 9 ER earlier this year
4 Sonny Gray at NYY Tue? Salmonella poisoning has really taken its toll so he might not even make this start; avoid til post-ASB
5 Michael Pineda at BOS Fri 55% of his ER have come in four terrible outings; but he has a 2.18 ERA in the 11 other starts
6 Jeff Samardzija TOR Thu Shark back on track of late (3.00 ERA, 34 Ks in last 36 IP), but TOR is hard on all pitchers so it’s a gamble
7 Chris Sale TOR Mon I’m obligated to mention the awesomeness of TOR v. LHP, but I think Sale’s awesomeness will win out here

THE BULLPENS RANKED 1-30

Bullpens are the most volatile part of the game year-to-year. Look at any breakout team and there’s a good chance their bullpen performance from the previous year has improved substantially. Obviously KC’s bullpen is a high profile example, but it’s hardly new. The small samples create a ton of variance, but I can’t overreact to every week of data from the bullpens so unless I see real reasons behind the performance – for better or worse –then I’m not going to drastically move a team around. Commentary will be included every other week since there aren’t always drastic changes in the bullpens week-to-week.

THE BULLPENS RANKED 1-30

RK TEAM LAST KEY COMPONENTS
1 HOU 1 Gregerson, Harris, Neshek
2 LAD 2 Jansen, Nicasio, Liberatore
3 KC 4 Holland, Davis, Madson
4 BAL 3 Britton, O’Day, Brach
5 NYY 6 Betances, Shreve, Wilson
6 MIA 7 Ramos, Dyson, Capps
7 MIL 5 K-Rod, Smith, Blazek
8 PIT 8 Melancon, Watson, Hughes
9 STL 11 Rosenthal, Siegrist, Maness
10 CHC 10 Rondon, Strop, Motte
11 TB 9 Boxberger, Jepsen, McGee
12 CLE 12 Allen, Shaw, McAllister
13 WAS 17 Storen, Treinen, Rivero
14 TOR 13 Osuna, Delabar, Loup
15 NYM 15 Familia, C.Torres, A.Torres
16 CWS 16 Robertson, Duke, Petricka
17 SD 20 Kimbrel, Maurer, Benoit
18 PHI 14 Papelbon, Giles, De Fratus
19 OAK 21 Clippard, Scribner, Otero
20 ARI 24 Ziegler, Delgado, Hudson
21 SF 19 Casilla, Romo, Kontos
22 LAA 22 Street, Smith, Salas
23 CIN 23 Chapman, Hoover, Badenhop
24 TEX 25 Tolleson, Kela, Claudio
25 SEA 18 Smith, Wilhelmsen, Rodney
26 ATL 27 Grilli, J.Johnson, Martin
27 COL 26 Hawkins, Betancourt, Friedrich
28 BOS 28 Uehara, Tazawa, Ogando
29 MIN 30 Perkins, Fien, Pressly
138 DET 29 Soria, Nesbitt, Wilson

About the Author

PSporer
PSporer

Paul has been writing about baseball for 15 years at various internet outlets and he’s been an avid fantasy baseballer for 21 of his 33 years on this planet, joining his first league at 12 years old which is still running today. He writes a comprehensive starting pitcher guide each year and it’s now available thespguide.com. When’s he’s not watching baseball, he is sleeping, because why would anyone waste time being awake if they weren’t going to watch baseball? He writes three times a week and has his own podcast at Fangraphs with co-hosts Eno Sarris & Jason Collette, contributes to Rotowire, and he has been a guest co-host with Matthew Berry on ESPN’s Fantasy Focus podcast.